Celebrating and Protesting Israel’s Birth: From Jerusalem to the Sidewalks of New York

May 9, 2008 by Phyllis Chesler  
Filed under News

(Written with the help of Fern Sidman)

As a child, my mother took me to the Radio City Music Hall to see the dazzling, long-limbed Rockettes dance. For decades, the Music Hall symbolized glitzy entertainment, New York style. Radio City was also where I went when I was interviewed on NBC and when I dined at the Big Band-era Rainbow Room, a 65th floor precursor to and survivor of the World Trade Center’s Windows on the World. The Rainbow Room also has windows that look out onto the immediate world.

On Wednesday evening, May 7th, Jews around the world celebrated the miraculous 60th anniversary of the birth of Israel as a modern state. In New York City, an historic extravaganza took place at Radio City Music Hall. An attempt to Palestinianize this Art Deco palace also took place. It failed, it did not interrupt the considerable joy within but still, the Haters are everywhere, there is no event they do not picket.

Wherever one turns, one finds the same monotonous anti-Israeli, anti-American, and pro-Palestinian propaganda. It has invaded our air waves, our campuses, and the entire global internet. Complex realities and wrenching truths have been reduced to lying, paranoid hate speech which wraps itself in the righteous garments of “oppression” and “liberation.” On the march, its face is raging and hateful.

In Israel, its Arab citizens attended a mass rally and march to mark the 60th anniversary of “the Naqba” (Catastrophe). According to Ynet, Violence flared up when the Palestinian organizers failed to control their own demonstrators who repeatedly clashed with Israeli police and civilians. Five Israeli police were injured. A group of peaceful, young Israeli members who belong to the volunteer group,”If You Will,” raised an Israeli flag at a picnic-in their own country, as they celebrated their Independence. The Arab demonstrators demanded that they lower the flag. Arguments broke out. Violence ensued.

My colleague, the journalist Fern Sidman, called me from Radio City Music Hall. She sounded upset, anything but jubilant.

Continue Reading on Chesler Chronicles >>

Comments & Trackbacks

2 Responses to “Celebrating and Protesting Israel’s Birth: From Jerusalem to the Sidewalks of New York”

Trackbacks

_____________________________________________________________

Comments

  1. fouse, gary c on May 10th, 2008 6:27 pm

    Nonie Darwish at UC-Irvine

    This week, I was fortunate to be able to hear Nonie Darwish speak at UC-Irvine as part of the week-long celebration of Israel’s 60th birthday. I have previously written about Darwish in my blog (Three Muslim Heretics). Briefly, she was born in Cairo and has lived in Gaza. Her father fought against Israel and was eventually killed by Israeli forces. Thus, she grew up hating everything about the Jewish state and Jews in general. Subsequent to 9-11, she rejected Muslim violence, broke with the religion and has become an active voice against Jihad. She is the author of a book entitled: Now they call me Infidel.

    I wish I could say that there was a big crowd to hear her presentation (which was coupled with a film entitled: The Suicide Killers). However, the turnout was quite small-about 20 or so people-including her bodyguards. I was the only faculty member there.

    Darwish began by describing her early upbringing in the Middle East and her feelings of hatred toward Jews, which she attributed to the death of her father as well as the way Arab youth were educated in Cairo to hate Jews. She also made some important observations about the general outlook on the part of Muslims that we in the West should be aware of. I will mention them below in no particular order.

    The penalty for a Muslim who leaves the religion is death.

    She quoted the part of the Koran that describes when Jews will hide behind trees and rocks and the tree will tell Muslims that there is a Jew hiding behind (the tree)-come and kill him).

    In the Koran, according to Darwish, in 97% of the references to Jihad, it is the context of fighting against non-believers. Only in about 3% of cases is Jihad described as a struggle to be a better person, etc.

    She described how in Israel, Muslims are free to practice their religion freely, unlike in Muslim countries, where a Jew would be killed if he walked down the street wearing a yarmulke or other item that marked him as a Jew.

    She derided Muslim efforts to have American universities and airports install foot baths. In the Middle East, only Saudi Arabia has public foot baths to her knowledge. She also pointed out that many US universities receive funding from Middle Eastern sources such as Saudi Arabia- a nation that promotes Wahhabi teaching among Muslims in the West. (note: At UC-Irvine, the MSU receives funding from the university-taken from student tuition fees.)

    In regards to Saudi Arabia, she recounted how just recently, a top religious leader has issued a Fatwa calling for the murder of two Saudis who had publicly called for moderation within Islam.

    She also spoke of so-called “Honor Killings”, recounting the story of a young maid in her childhood home who had become pregnant as a result of being raped. After Darwish’s family assisted the girl to find refuge with a social services agency, they learned later that the girl had been returned to her family. Her father and her brother then murdered her-for the shame of being raped-in accordance with Shariah law. In Muslim countries, such “honor killings” are treated leniently under the law.

    Perhaps most alarmingly, she warned against creeping Shariah in the West, which would impose Muslim rules within our countries.

    In her mind, there is no real difference between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism.

    Darwish noted how America has struggled for many years to overcome our own prejudices and cautioned us against allowing new prejudices to enter our country (i.e.: Muslim prejudice against Jews).

    I am sorry that so few people turned out to hear the words of this courageous woman. As I stated above, I was the only faculty member present (and I am only a part-time teacher at that). In contrast, fired DePaul professor and terrorist sympathizer, Norman Finklestein’s anti-Israel monologue this week was attended by Dean of Students, Sally Peterson, who took copius notes and Dean of Judicial Affairs, Edgar Dormitorio, who tried to get a pro-Israel supporter, Jonathan Constantine, to sit down while he was filming. But they could not bring themselves to hear the words of a woman who has put her life on the line to oppose Muslim terror. Dormitorio, for his part, was pacing outside the hall where Darwish spoke, yet would not come in to hear what she had to say. Why is this? Is it because they were unsympathetic to Ms Darwish’s point of view? Was it because they were afraid to offend the Muslim Student Union? A combination of the two? Ms Darwish’s theme was a rejection of hate. Yet, that was apparently not of interest to those who teach and lead UC-Irvine. They would rather pander to a tiny minority of students who have brought national disrepute to their campus.

    What a collection of empty suits.

    gary fouse
    adjunct teacher
    uci-ext
    fousesquawk

  2. Colonel Robert Neville on May 12th, 2008 5:06 am

    Dear Gary:

    Hey, thanks for the informative adendum. Hideously, this behaviour of rejecting any Jew, Conservative or ex-Left Liberal or ex-Muslim or present Christian, and accepting any Muslim, Islamist, Leftard, radical, convicted criminal ad nauseum, is now bog standard and across the board.

    Three weeks ago, I attended a rare presentation by the soft spoken, urbane, intelligent and eminent Daniel Pipes, at Caulfield Camps in Melbourne Australia. While there was about 200 people, which is not many really, there was no press and we were all fans anyway.

    My take on the event. http://colonelrobertneville.blogspot.com/2008/05/pipes-dream-of-attitude-for-victory.html

    The only answer to dealing with the assorted freaks and wilfully deluded anti-Semites allied against Israel, and they certainly are a cavalcade of not so strange bedfellows, is the same as in martial arts and boxing: Prepare, deflect, block and hit hard, then repeat as necassary. Metaphorically OR literally.

    Now I simply must wear a t-shirt that says “I support Israel” and maybe with the ad on, “Wanna fight?” or “So fuck you”. Either way, you’ll get a few laughs.

    I don’t wanna play some freaks game of arguing about it. I don’t give a damn what some creep has to say one way or the other. I know EXACTLY their true intent and goal…They just hate Jews…Ya don’t need to hear and be bored by anyone’s meagre, phony, logical fallacy, cognitive bias laden and evil opinions.

    Whatever happens to Israel, will happen to us all…eventually.

    All the best, kid. The answer is strength, courage, confidence, faith, flexibility and a total attitude for total victory. And yes, the MSM is no friend of Israel or the Jews.

    Colonel Robert Neville.

_____________________________________________________________

This comment section is for the readers of Ft. Hard Knox, a place for political conservatives to share information about online activism. We are not "fair and balanced," and we aren't refereeing a "free speech zone." Intelligent, funny, and on-topic comments are welcome. Trolls, spam, and liberal propaganda are not. We may occassionally approve a comment with an obvious lefty-slant so that we can amuse ourselves by making fun of it, but most will be deleted. (Why? Because we're busy, we have lives, and when we want to talk to you we'll go visit you on Digg or the Daily KOS.)

This is a private blog, and we reserve the right to make up our own rules as we go along. The few comments which manage to squeak by our censors reflect the opinion of the commentator, and not necessarily the staff of Ft. Hard Knox.

...and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!





Bad Behavior has blocked 6419 access attempts in the last 7 days.