Who broke the circle?

Posted June 18th, 2008 by forthardknox

…from Alec, of the Error Theory Blog:

Blogburst logo, petition

The Memorial Project claims to have an innocent explanation for why the central feature of the Flight 93 memorial is a giant Islamic shaped crescent. As architect Paul Murdoch has been saying since September 2005, the flight path breaks the circle, turning it into what was originally called the Crescent of Embrace.

But this isn’t a memorial to an airliner. It is a memorial to human beings. So just who is it that architect Paul Murdoch is depicting as breaking the circle?

As a secular symbol, the circle signifies peace and harmony. There is no way that the heroic passengers and crew can be charged with breaking the circle. It is the terrorists who broke the peace.

Think what that means thematically. The terrorists broke our peaceful circle and turned it into a giant Islamic shaped crescent that just happens to point to Mecca. You could not come up with a more blatant depiction of al Qaeda victory.

This is what the Park Service is claiming as an innocent explanation: that they are depicting a circle-breaking crescent-creating action that logically can only be attributed to the terrorists. Are they really too dumb to figure out what that means?

Take action

How about a couple hundred of us call up the Memorial Project (814 443-4557) and ask them just who is being depicted as “breaking the circle”? If they try to say “Flight 93 broke it,” we can ask for clarification. Do they really mean to include our forty heroes amongst those who broke the peace?

They might even admit that it can only be the terrorists who are depicted as turning the circle into a crescent, and they might even realize: “oops.”

Maybe we should send a few emails as well, and cc the local press, who might be prompted to ask Memorial Project spokesmen how they are answering our pointed questions. (Click link for addressed email form. Feel free to cut and paste text from above. Sincerely, your name and state.)

Share this with a friend!
[del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Twitter] [Email] More »
Tagged and categorized as: Uncategorized , , Comments (8)

8 Responses to “Who broke the circle?”

  1. Park Service refuses to say who broke the circle | The Hinge Of Fate
    June 25th, 2008 - 8:14 am

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  2. Park Service refuses to say who broke the circle
    June 25th, 2008 - 8:18 am

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  3. Flight 93 Memorial Blogburst #35 « Nice Deb
    June 25th, 2008 - 8:48 am

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  4. Flight 93 Blogburst « A Defending Crusader…
    June 25th, 2008 - 10:18 am

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  5. Flight 93 Memorial Update… &laquo Publius’ Forum
    June 25th, 2008 - 4:01 pm

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  6. Stop the Murdoch (Flt 93) Memorial Blogburst: Park Service refuses to say who broke the circle | Chaotic Synaptic Activity
    June 25th, 2008 - 10:17 pm

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  7. Flight 93 memorial blogburst: Sign the petition to stop the memorial | Haid Dasalami
    June 26th, 2008 - 12:29 am

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails demanding to know WHO is being [...]

  8. Flopping Aces » Blog Archive » Flight 93 Memorial Blogburst: Park Service Refuses To Say Who Broke The Circle
    June 30th, 2008 - 8:01 am

    [...] last week, the Park Service has been inundated with hundreds of emails, demanding to know WHO is being [...]